Don’t Stand Too Close To The Housing Market Eruption
Watching a volcanic eruption is like watching a waterfall, right?
People in Iceland are just casually hanging out on an active volcano pic.twitter.com/FRV2hts60h
— Wu-Tang Is For The Children (@WUTangKids) March 22, 2021
But I digress…
Tangible Reasons Why The U.S. Housing Market Is Not In A Bubble
Many wonder if we are entering or already in a housing bubble with rapid housing price growth. I’ve maintained we are not because lending conditions remain tighter than historical normals (looking well before the GFC era)
Barry Ritholtz at The Big Picture post Is it a Bubble? GS Edition with this super interesting chart on famous financial bubbles as well as Ray Dalio’s checklist:
Item 5 below is what seems to be missing at the moment.
1. Excessive price appreciation and extreme valuations 2. New valuation approaches justified
3. Increased market concentration
4. Frantic speculation and investor flows
5. Easy credit, low rates and rising leverage
6. Booming corporate activity
7. ‘New era’ narrative and technology innovations
8. Late-cycle economic boom
9. The emergence of accounting scandals and irregularities
Felix Salmon over on his Axios Capital newsletter shows us why the Canadian housing is in a bubble, and the U.S. is probably not – U.S. home prices are rising faster than mortgage debt:
The Palm Beach Luxury Real Estate Flip Fest Is A Thing
After me downplaying growing bubble talk, let’s talk about a 113% annualized rate of growth on a luxury flip in Palm Beach.
EXCLUSIVE: Billionaire Steve Wynn’s company sells Palm Beach house for $23.67 million [Shiny Sheet]
The casino magnate paid $18.4 million for the home at 235 Via Vizcaya in late December, property records show.
Palm Beach has been a hot-bed of high sales activity in a market defined by high end activity.
New Yorker Cover: Spring Is Almost Here!
Census: Changing Homeownership Rates
There don’t seem to be any big patterns in homeownership growth – southeast coastline, northern Texas, northern California coastline seem to stand out.
Despite Large Declines, Coastal Urban Rents Remain Stratospheric
From howmuch.net – Top 25 Most (and Least) Expensive American Cities to Rent an Apartment
New in the Real Estate Lexicon: COVAX
How the real estate brokers in Palm Beach refer to the COVID housing market.
Len Kiefer‘s Chart Handiwork
(For earlier appraisal industry commentary, visit my old clunky REIC site.)
Project Teams: The Appraisal Institute Practices Recycling, But Doesn’t Take Out The Trash
One of the frustrations of AI membership has been how the organization has not kept up with changing times, but instead, focusing its energies on workarounds to keep long-time FOJs in power and circulation. And this lets FOJs keep the money rolling in by overpaying executives and letting them fly business class with their emotional support spouses and other lackeys all over the world without actual benefit to the members. The collective braintrust of the Appraisal Institute is quite impressive so why not bring in new ideas and new leadership? The organization as it is currently run, is unable to see ahead of the curve without an influx of new thinking. The world has changed and the Appraisal Institute has not – this is why the organization continues to drift into irrelevance to the outside world and why people like me are so concerned about the damage their negligence is causing to the profession.
I’ve been covering the Sham Petition Process quite a bit over the past year, chronicling its utilization and the fraud it represents. The organizational pivot to its current sorry state was a measurable moment in time: 2007 when the Sham Petition Process was invented to get Leslie Sellers into the ranks for the eventual presidency by 2010 after failing to win the NNC approval, and actually voted for himself instead of recusing. In 2010, I saw his AI video, which announced the exit of AI from TAF, and was disgusted by his reasoning (paraphrased) “We are so excited about our future, now having the freedom to grow.” I left AI at that point and watched its membership ranks fall by about 30%.
We saw the Sham Petition Process maneuver’s return that attempted to ram FOJ favorite “Tank” down the membership’s throat (which he willingly threw his name into the hat) to cancel the NNC choice who had already publicly announced, Craig Steinley.
That’s not the only reason FOJs work hard to control every move of the Appraisal Institute. Stacking committees with FOJs and using the formation of project teams to crush dissent has been another way.
Here’s the difference between “committees and “project teams:”
Project Teams Presidential Appointment, No BoD approval, No Money available, Report to the Executive Committee (and usually die after three years, not accountable).
Project teams are used for political purposes, often to kill an insurgency by placating in the short term and then doing nothing about the issue. For example, the residential appraiser project team was formed back in 2017 and had about thirty members. Jim Amorin formed it to appease the membership during the uprising of residential members when AI Headquarters plotted to take control of chapter dues. The project team never meets and has not done a single thing yet to advance the residential profession. Shameful. By 2018-19 the membership was down to about ten members and still has not done anything. Why would someone be a member of a team that does nothing?
And membership on these project teams is not made public like committees are. Why is that? What about transparency?
Committees Appointed by President but must have BoD Approval, Budget with money, Chair reports to BoD at Quarterly meetings (accountable).
Here are some glaring examples of keeping the older FOJ ex-leadership in positions of influence – I have heard there are about 40 positions available each year, and about 400 apply. With 17K members, I would think it would be a snap to fill 100% of these committee openings with new members every year. Instead, AI recycles some of the worst leadership the organization has ever had, allowing Jim Amorin to run the organization like a dictator and not be concerned about its members.
Member name (# of committees) Comment
Steve Roach (6)
Claire Aufrance (3) inspired the term “emotional support spouse”
Terry Dunkin (3) 2007 President and in charge when AI leadership went sour
Jim Murrett (3) 2018 President
Nick Pilz (3)
Mike Tankersley (2) participated in the 2020 sham petition process
Leslie Sellers (1) 2010 President – petition process was created in 2007 to get him in line for the presidency
Why is this happening? This is poor governance 101. How can an organization evolve when the same people are in positions of power for years? To be blunt, dinosaurs representing a failed institutional legacy should not be on these committees if the organization wants to grow and remain relevant.
And why is an executive such Jim Amorin on the Government Relations Committee?
C’mon AI President and BoD, please get to work to stop this hostile institutional takeover before the authorities do.
Bloomberg’s CITYLAB Incorrectly Blames Appraisers For Redlining
This excellent piece Redlined, Now Flooding made a mistake and it is part of the growing false narrative that Brookings and many real estate journalists are perpetuating.
Unfortunately, the appraisal industry’s two largest organizations have been long mired in their own internal self-dealing that they no longer have the backs of appraisers. Appraisers are exposed with no one taking action to represent us other than pithy press releases.
The problem with this piece is the journalists conflate banks and appraisers – the appraisers appraised houses that were mortgaged by banks, who redlined applicants. The banks redlined, not the appraisers. This presentation makes it sound as though the appraisers determined who was redlined. I’m not excusing systemic racism but this is a mischaracterization of what happened. Redlining is what federal agencies and banks were built on during the Great Depression and afterwards. I have pointed this out to Citylab.
Dave Towne On Unlawful Restrictive Covenants
This is from appraiser Dave Towne (email him to get on his distribution list):
There has been considerable discussion about ‘bias’ applying to appraisals on forums, and elsewhere, since the Congressional hearing in 2018 where appraisers were blamed for racial bias by the rep from the Brookings Institute.
That rep vilified appraisers as being the culprits in the lending process, which is mostly bogus. Unfortunately, now that the charge has been made, appraisers and appraisal organizations are now forced to play on the defensive side of the ball, rather than being proactive and disclosing what actually transpired, on offense. I sense appraisal organizations are afraid to tell the real story. And it’s been real hard to disprove the negative. Appraisers are easy targets.
The fact is, appraisers as an independent entity, had almost NO involvement in the restrictions that governments and lenders instituted beginning in the early years of this country. I recently read a tidbit of history disclosing how a former mayor of Las Vegas, NV forced a certain ethnic group to relocate their businesses and homes to a different part of the city, out of downtown. This was not the only place in this country where it happened. Other ethnic groups have been forced to live underground (really) in certain cities because they were not respected ‘topside.’ Yet, it was those ‘below ground’ people who enabled the ‘topside’ folks to prosper greatly.
Lenders early on, and into the 1950’s, were probably the worst of the bunch in the way they established ‘approved’ neighborhoods and ‘disapproved’ other neighborhoods for lending purposes. I don’t need to repeat the common term that was used verbally and on maps during those times.
Race and ethnicity divisions has been a global issue since humans first walked upright and began functioning. This is not a uniquely US problem, or one associated directly with appraisers. Humans have a propensity to segregate themselves as a natural course of existence. There is no magic wand that will cure this despite what some think and are trying to force on society.
Meanwhile, appraisers have had to figure out which properties were the most appropriate when doing an appraisal….and those were most likely from the specific neighborhood(s) where the ethnic or racial borrower was located so that the report would ‘pass muster’ and be usable for the requested loan. When the property was “here” the lenders didn’t want comparables used from “over there”, otherwise the lender probably would not approve the loan.
So it’s not really the appraiser at fault for not ‘helping’ certain people rise economically, as often is the charge. Appraisers have been stifled, discouraged, even threatened from doing so, since appraising became a US profession in the mid-1930’s.
Tonight, when I was doing research for something totally different, I found this info (below and in the attached PDF) on a Washington State county auditor web site…..which I’ve never seen before.
I would encourage all appraisers to research their own property deed, and contact the appropriate ‘recording official’ in your state to see if this is being done, or can be done, where you are. More info is in the PDF.
ATTACHMENT (Washington State county auditor)
What are racially restrictive covenants?
In the first half of the twentieth century, restrictive covenants were recorded on some properties in Washington which included racially restrictive provisions. These racially restrictive covenants sometimes singled out specific races that were excluded from owning or occupying the property. Other versions would limit ownership or use to one particular race. Sometimes the restrictive covenants limited ownership or use by members of certain religions.
Are racially restrictive covenants valid and enforceable?
No. In 1948 the United States Supreme Court ruled that racially restrictive covenants could not be enforced. In 1968 the federal Fair Housing Act banned covenants discriminating on the basis of race, color, religion, or national origin.
OFT (One Final Thought)
Old time NYC videos can’t be beat.
“It’s a long way to the street, boys.”
A 1929 colorized video of construction workers on the Chrysler building in New York.
At 1,046 feet it is the tallest brick building in the world with a steel framework, and was world's tallest building for 11 months after its completion in 1930. pic.twitter.com/cGBf1fr0fK
— Vala Afshar (@ValaAfshar) March 21, 2021
And one on street level…
Brilliant Idea #1
If you need something rock solid in your life (particularly on Friday afternoons) and someone forwarded this to you, or you think you already subscribed, sign up here for these weekly Housing Notes. And be sure to share with a friend or colleague if you enjoy them because:
– They’ll be more volcanic;
– You’ll erupt;
– And I’ll hang out next to waterfalls.
Brilliant Idea #2
You’re obviously full of insights and ideas as a reader of Housing Notes. I appreciate every email I receive and it helps me craft the next week’s Housing Note.
See you next week.
Reads, Listens and Visuals I Enjoyed
- Is it a Bubble? GS Edition [The Big Picture-Ritholtz]
- Despite Devastating Effects on the Broader Economy, Pandemic Has Been a Boon for US Home Improvement [JCHS Harvard]
- Changing Homeownership Rates [Census]
- EXCLUSIVE: Billionaire Steve Wynn’s company sells Palm Beach house for $23.67 million [Palm Beach Daily News]
- East Coast homeowners fight rising risks of climate change [CNBC]
- How to End the War Over the Future of the Suburbs [Bloomberg]
- What Does Home Mean to Us? Not the Same Thing It Did Before the Pandemic [NY Times]
- Existing home sales fell sharply in February, as supply dropped by the largest amount on record [CNBC]
- Someone Is Really Moving Into Jeffrey Epstein’s Haunted Mansion [The Cut]
- The Effect of Mortgage Forbearance on House Prices During COVID-19 [Federal Reserve]
- Compass Seeks $10B Valuation at IPO [The Real Deal]
- The Cheapest and Most Expensive Cities to Rent an Apartment in America [How Much]
- Jeffrey Epstein’s Mansion to Undergo ‘Complete Makeover’ [NY Times]
- Opinion | Rents for the rich are plummeting. Rents for the poor are rising. Why? [Washington Post]
- Miami’s Little Manhattan [Curbed]
- New Realtors Pile Into Hot Housing Market. Most Find It Tough Going [Wall Street Journal]
- Historically Redlined Neighborhoods Face Far Higher Flood Risks [Bloomberg]
- What If Housing Prices Aren’t As High As They Appear? [A Wealth of Common Sense]
My New Content, Research and Mentions
- Florida’s feelgood factor lures out-of-state buyers [Financial Times]
- Columbia Pacific Advisors secures $13.75 million bridge loan [New York Real Estate Journal]
- Pharma Billionaire Stewart Rahr to Sell Hamptons Estate [The Real Deal]
Recently Published Elliman Market Reports
- Elliman Report: Manhattan, Brooklyn & Queens Rentals 2-2021 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Colorado New Signed Contracts 2-2021 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: California New Signed Contracts 2-2021 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Florida New Signed Contracts 2-2021 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: New York New Signed Contracts 2-2021 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Manhattan Decade 2011-2020 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Manhattan Townhouse Decade 2011-2020 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Manhattan, Brooklyn & Queens Rentals 1-2021 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Hamptons/North Fork Decade 2011-2020 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Long Island Decade 2011-2020 [Miller Samuel]
Appraisal Related Reads
- Is This Discrimination? [Cleveland Appraisal Blog]
- An Educated Guess As to Why USPAP Was Extended [Jonathan Miller/Appraisers Blogs]
- How to Fight Blacklisting [Working RE]
- Forms Redesign Extended Into 2023-24 [Dave Towne/Appraisers Blogs]
- 5 Things Agents MUST Provide The Appraiser In Today’s Hot Market [Tom Horn/Birmingham Appraisal Blog]
- Skyrocketing prices aren’t happening everywhere [Ryan Lundquist/Sacramento Appraisal Blog]